Classic P2P lending platforms: what changed in November
Defaults at Lendwise, NEO Finance, The Money Platform and EvenFi, plus news from SAVY, Mustard, Digilo, Unbolted and JustUs for direct P2P lenders.
- Investing in Loans
Questions about investing? Ask the AI guide.
Hi! I'm the Crowdinform AI guide.
Sign in free to ask the AI guide about platforms, projects and your plans.
Answers come from Crowdinform's checked data. Information, not personal investment advice.
Looking it up… Something went wrong. Please try again. {n} questions left todayArticle Loan originators Advanced
Our country memo for the Philippines: can borrowers pay, will the rules change, will the currency hold, and can lenders recover money? Grade D, 2.26 out of 5.
Key takeaways
How risky is the Philippines for investors who lend through P2P platforms? Our country memo looks at five questions: can borrowers keep paying, will the government change the rules, will the currency hold, could politics break the business, and can lenders recover money through the courts. Our grade for the Philippines: D (2.26 out of 5).
Written 14 November 2026 · Applies to every loan originator lending in the Philippines; the one in view is Warm Cash Lending Corp. (Honey Loan, Well Cash), a Manila online consumer lender funded in euros through Nectaro (via SIA Abele Finance) · Review again after: the BSP's 17 December 2026 rate decision; any SEC change to the interest cap; a Fitch rating action; the Senate verdict on Vice President Sara Duterte; the House vote on the fair-debt-collection bill; a peso move of more than 10% against the euro.
THIS IS NOT FINANCIAL ADVICE. This country memo was prepared with the help of AI from publicly available documents. It is general information for education only. It is not investment advice, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any loan, note or security, and does not take account of your personal circumstances. Figures, calculations and conclusions may contain errors — verify them against the original filings before acting. Investing through P2P platforms can result in the loss of all money invested. If in doubt, consult a licensed financial adviser.
| Country grade | Framework limit | Biggest risk | Getting better or worse? |
|---|---|---|---|
| D — High (2.26 out of 5) | 5% of a portfolio in Philippine LOs | Stagflation hitting the borrowers while the regulator tightens. Inflation reached 7.8% in October 2026, growth fell to 2.1% in the third quarter, and unemployment rose from 3.8% to 5.4% in a year. The SEC cut the all-in cap on small loans from 15% to 12% a month from April 2026; Honey Loan already prices at 12%. | Worse, fast. Inflation averaged 1.7% in 2025. Since then the peso set 31 record lows against the dollar, reserves fell 12%, the BSP raised rates four times, Fitch moved to a negative outlook and government debt reached 66.9% of GDP. |
The three things that matter most
No veto applies. There is no default, no capital control that we found, and no ban: the SEC reopened registration of new online lending platforms on 1 August 2026. The 12% cap is not below an efficient lender's cost to serve plus cost of risk, as far as public data shows. It is below Warm Cash's 2025 running costs, but that is a company problem.
What would change the grade. Up to C (2.60+): inflation and the peso steady (macro and FX to 3) plus one quiet political year gives 2.68. Down to E (below 1.80): a second cap cut together with a recession and a peso fall gives 1.76; capital controls would also mean E.
In 2025 the Philippine economy grew 4.4%. In 2026 two shocks hit together. An oil shock from the Middle East war raised fuel prices in a country that imports its fuel. A corruption scandal over flood-control projects froze public construction and hurt confidence. The result is stagflation: growth 2.1% in the third quarter, inflation 7.8% in October, a 44-month high. The central bank (BSP) has raised its rate to 5.50%.
Online lending to consumers is legal and licensed by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and it is politically unpopular. The police anti-organised-crime commission counted 47,446 complaints against online lenders in eighteen months. The SEC lowered the cost cap and raised capital rules, and the Senate passed a fair-debt-collection bill.
The government is rated investment grade (BBB+, BBB, Baa2). Politics are noisy but institutional: the Vice President is on trial in the Senate, her father awaits trial at the International Criminal Court, and the next presidential election is in May 2028. There is a live dispute with China at sea, but no war. The Philippines scores 2.26, a D, a little below Indonesia (2.41), Romania (2.39) and Kazakhstan (2.38) in this series.
| Detail | |
|---|---|
| Typical borrower | An urban wage earner or informal worker. The Metro Manila non-farm minimum wage is ₱755 a day (≈€10.70 at 70.526 pesos per euro), up from ₱695. Unemployment is 5.4% (2.86m people); underemployment 11.0% (5.56m). |
| What they borrow | Small app loans. Honey Loan: ₱1,000–₱30,000 over 61–364 days, "Monthly Effective Interest Rate: 12%", "Maximum APR: 144%". |
| Income sources | Wages, self-employment and remittances. Personal remittances were US$26.1bn in January–August 2026, up 2.3%: less than half the inflation rate. |
| What hits them first | Fuel, transport and rice. The bottom 30% of households faced 6.8% average inflation in January–October. With typhoons, agriculture contracted 4.8% in the third quarter; rice (palay) and corn output fell more than 17%. |
| Loan originator | Group and funding | What it lends and its accounts | Our grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warm Cash Lending Corp. (Honey Loan, Well Cash) | Owned by Dyninno Fintech Holding (Cyprus) since 2024. Funded by euro loans, including EUR 4.20m from SIA Abele Finance (32% of Abele's loans at end-2025). 18.66% of Nectaro's outstanding principal on 14 Nov 2026. | Cash loans at 12% a month. FY2025 audited: net loss PHP 99.4m, equity −PHP 127.9m, "material uncertainty related to going concern", euro loans payable PHP 361.7m at 15.40–19.40%. SEC registration 2021030009095-02. The Certificate of Authority is No. 3472 on its website and No. 3427 in its accounts; not confirmed on the SEC's record. | E (company memo of 14 Nov 2026, not yet published) |
Other platforms' Philippine lenders were not checked in this run.
What this tells us. Borrowers are many, low-paid and losing real income in 2026, and they borrow at up to 12% a month. The only exposure we track is a young, loss-making lender whose euro loans sit above negative equity. The country grade sets the ceiling; the company memo explains why Warm Cash sits well below it.
| 2024 | 2025 | Latest 2026 | Trend | What it means | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GDP growth | 5.7% | 4.4% | 2.1% (Q3); 2.5% (Q1–Q3) | ▼ | Household spending +2.4% in Q3; public construction down for a sixth quarter. |
| Inflation | 3.2% | 1.7% | 7.8% (Oct); 5.6% Jan–Oct average | ▲ | Target 2–4%. Core average 4.0%: rises are spreading beyond fuel. |
| Unemployment | 3.8% | 4.2% | 5.4% (Sep; 3.8% a year earlier) | ▲ | 909,000 more unemployed in a year. |
| Remittances | +3.0% | +3.3% | +2.3% (Jan–Aug) | ▼ | Slower than prices. |
| Consumer confidence | — | −22.2 (Q4) | −42.0 (Q2), −29.8 (Q3) | ▼ | The deepest pessimism in the BSP series shown (2023–26). |
| Bank NPLs | 3.0% | 2.8% | 3.3% system, end-June; bad loans +10.3% to ₱585bn | ▲ | The BSP: "some unsecured consumer lending segments were showing pressure". |
| Online-lending arrears | — | — | not confirmed (not published) | ? | We cannot measure this market's losses. |
What this tells us. A year ago the economy would have earned a 3; now it earns a 2. Growth has halved, inflation is at a 44-month high, unemployment is up by 900,000 and confidence has collapsed. Banks already see stress in unsecured consumer loans, and online borrowers are poorer than bank borrowers. The blind spot is the online market itself: nobody publishes its arrears.
| Rule | Today | Changed recently? | Effect on an LO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maximum cost of a loan | SEC Memorandum Circular 14 of 2025 (issued 10 December 2025; older than six months). It covers unsecured loans of up to ₱10,000 for up to four months: nominal interest at most 6% a month; all-in effective rate (excluding penalties) at most 12% a month (≈0.40% a day); penalties at most 5% a month; total cost at most 100% of principal. It applies to loans "entered into, restructured, or renewed beginning on April 1, 2026". Fines: ₱50,000 for a first offence, then up to ₱1m and/or a 60-day suspension; a third offence revokes the company's certificate of authority and certificate of incorporation. Before: BSP Circular 1133 (Monetary Board, 16 December 2021) set "6 percent per month", an effective "15 percent per month", "5 percent per month" penalties and a "total cost cap of 100 percent … regardless of time the loan has been outstanding". It was a "time-bound relief measure", "subject to the periodic review". | Yes: from 15% to 12% a month in April 2026. The SEC says the caps "shall be subject to a periodic review". | Honey Loan prices exactly at 12%. Any further cut goes straight to its income. |
| Licensing | The SEC licenses lenders under RA 9474 (2007) and may suspend or revoke them. SEC MC 20 of 2026 (7 July 2026) "formally lifts the moratorium on … new Online Lending Platforms … effective 1 August 2026, after almost five years". Paid-up capital: ₱5m for a lending company, ₱10m–₱50m with one to five apps; at most five apps; 12 months to comply; a single Certificate of Authority; a licensing fee on assets from 2027. Revocations continue (e.g. Delisha Lending, June 2026, headline). | Yes: August 2026 | More capital per app by about August 2027. Whether Warm Cash (share capital ₱11m, negative equity) complies is not confirmed. |
| Collection and conduct | SEC MC 18 of 2019 bans threats, shaming and, "notwithstanding the borrower's consent, contacting the persons in the borrower's contact list other than those who were named as guarantors or co-makers". MC 20 adds disclosure, data-privacy and collection rules and bans "unauthorized loan disbursements and automatic renewals". RA 11765 (2022) lets the SEC fine, suspend and disqualify. | Yes: 2026. The Senate passed SB 1744, the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (headline, March 2026); no House vote found. | Collection only through the borrower and named guarantors, under fines and licence risk. |
| Is lending a political issue? | Yes. 47,446 complaints to PAOCC from August 2024 to January 2026, citing "threats, public shaming and unauthorized access to contact lists"; police cybercrime cases follow. No debt forgiveness found. | Hostile to abusive collection | Tightening on price and conduct, not a ban. |
Which lender. We found no public accounts of a typical, profitable Philippine online lender. So we use the lender in view: Warm Cash, audited for 2025, in pesos. It is young (its loan book grew from PHP 50.9m to 188.1m in 2025) and loss-making, so the test shows direction and size, not an industry average.
The €100. Its 2025 income of PHP 146.76m is our €100: interest 61.79m, fees 69.30m and other 15.67m, about €2.08m at 70.526. Running costs take 140 of it, credit losses 0 (no bad-debt charge was booked in 2025), interest on its euro loans 26 and a currency loss 1. That leaves −68, the reported loss of PHP 99.4m.
The stresses.
| Today (2025) | S1: cap halved | S2: losses at 2024 rate | S3: peso −20% | All three | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Income per €100 | 100 | 55 | 100 | 80 | 44 |
| Running costs | 140 | 140 | 140 | 112 | 112 |
| Credit losses | 0 | 0 | 30 | 0 | 24 |
| Interest on euro loans | 26 | 26 | 26 | 26 | 26 |
| Currency loss | 1 | 1 | 1 | 49 (one-off) | 49 (one-off) |
| Left over | −68 | −112 | −98 | −108 | −168 |
| Can it pay its lenders? | Only with owner support | No | No | No | No |
Rounded; unrounded: −67.7, −112.4, −97.8, −107.7, −167.5. In pesos: on a ₱10,000, 30-day loan the cap allows ₱1,200 of interest and fees today (₱1,500 before April 2026); a halving allows ₱600. Honey Loan's own example of ₱3,000 for 180 days costs ₱2,160 (72% of principal), under the 100% cap. Warm Cash's 2025 running costs were about 14.3% a month of its average book. That is our rough figure from two year-end balances, and it is above the cap. Its costs include professional fees of PHP 61.2m and marketing of PHP 31.4m.
What this tells us. The cap allows about 144% a year all-in and covers only loans up to ₱10,000 and four months. That leaves an efficient lender room to price for losses, so we do not apply the veto for a cap below cost to serve; an efficient lender's actual costs are not confirmed. A second cut to 6% a month (72% a year) would leave room only for lenders whose running costs and credit losses together stay below 72% of their book; Warm Cash's running costs alone were 172% in 2025. The SEC's "periodic review" is the most important rule event for Philippine originators.
| Value | What it means | |
|---|---|---|
| Peso against the euro | ECB, pesos per euro: 62.327 (13 Nov 2024), 68.418 (13 Nov 2025), 70.526 (13 Nov 2026, used in this memo); end-2024 60.301, end-2025 69.266; 12-month range 67.804–72.815. | The euro is up 3.1% in a year and 13.2% in two: the peso has lost 11.6% of its euro value. |
| Peso against the dollar | BSP: 58.805 (end-2025), 63.852 (end-October), 63.190 (12 November 2026); −7.59% in 2026 to October. A record close of ₱63.615 on 23 October was the year's 31st record low. | Steeper and recent. The euro's own fall against the dollar has softened the move for euro funders. |
| Central bank | Policy rate 5.50% since 23 October 2026, after a 50bp rise; cut to 4.25% in February, then raised four times from April (headlines). As reported, the BSP lets the market set the exchange rate and steps in only on large swings. | Orthodox, but behind inflation (7.8% against a 5.50% rate). |
| Reserves | US$97.35bn at end-October, down from US$110.83bn at end-2025 (−12.2%). That covers 6.1 months of imports and 310% of short-term external debt (7.3 months and 405% at end-2025). | Adequate but falling. |
| External position | Current-account deficit 6.4% of GDP in H1 2026 (4.3% a year earlier); goods imports +20.3%. Balance-of-payments deficit US$9.1bn to end-September. | Exposed to oil. |
| Controls and hedging | No outflow controls found. Warm Cash's euro loans fund peso loans with no hedge described. | Payments can leave. The mismatch sits with the lender. |
What this tells us. The peso has held up better against the euro (−3% in a year) than against the dollar. But the direction is down: an oil-driven deficit, reserves down by an eighth, and a central bank raising rates partly to hold the currency. For a lender with unhedged euro debt and negative equity, a 20% fall costs half a year's income at once.
| Question | Answer | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Is the government stable, and are elections coming? | President Marcos Jr. serves a single six-year term; the next election falls in May 2028. Vice President Sara Duterte, impeached again in 2026 (headline), is on trial in the Senate. Three of four charges were dropped, the conviction threshold was lowered from 16 to 14 votes, and a verdict "could be reached before year-end". Her father was committed to trial at the ICC on 23 April 2026 (older than six months). Fitch: the rift is "unlikely to undermine economic policymaking". | ● Watch |
| Sanctions? | None. | ● OK |
| Armed conflict? | At sea only. In July 2026 the China Coast Guard fired water cannon at Philippine vessels at Scarborough Shoal on two days, and a Filipino sailor was hit with a baton at Second Thomas Shoal. We considered the 'conflict on its territory' veto and do not apply it: payments and the cities are untouched. | ● Watch |
| Natural disasters | Typhoons and monsoon floods: agriculture contracted 4.8% in Q3 2026. | ● Watch |
| Corruption | CPI 2025: 32/100, 120th of 182, down from 33 and 114th of 180 in 2024, tied to the flood-control scandal (older than six months). DEPDev: "governance concerns and uncertainty also weighed on confidence". | ● Warning |
| Protests | Large and recurring. Up to 244 arrests in Manila in September 2025; for 21 September 2026 Manila police "banned public gatherings". | ● Watch |
What this tells us. There is no war, no sanctions and no payment block. But two political dynasties are in open legal conflict, and a corruption scandal has frozen public investment while living costs rise. Geopolitics scores 3: the China dispute is serious but stays at sea. Politics scores 2: the scandal is already costing growth.
| Question | Answer | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Recovery on a defaulted loan | For ₱1,000–₱30,000 loans, recovery is by collection under strict conduct rules, not by court. The small-claims ceiling is reported at ₱1,000,000 (not confirmed on a primary text). No recovery statistics were found. | ● Watch |
| Enforcement against lenders | The rules are policed jointly by PAOCC, the police cybercrime unit, the SEC and the privacy commission. Collection staff are exposed to criminal cases. | ● Warning |
| If the LO fails | We found no figures on recoveries by lenders to a failed Philippine lender. | ● Watch |
| Foreign lenders and owners | RA 9474 first required "at least a majority of the voting capital stock" to be Filipino-owned. RA 10881 (17 July 2016) replaced that section: "A lending company may be owned up to one hundred percent (100%) by foreign nationals". So Warm Cash's Cyprus owner is allowed. Its euro funders are unsecured. | ● Watch |
| Court quality | No WJP or Freedom House score found (not confirmed); CPI 32. | ● Warning |
What this tells us. A Philippine online lender is paid by its borrowers' willingness to pay and by its own collection desk, not by courts. The rules on collecting are strict and now enforced by the police. A foreign funder's claim sits on a local company, here one with negative equity.
| Parameter | Score | Weight | Weighted | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regulation: will the rules change? | 2 | 20% | 0.40 | The cap was cut in April 2026, with "periodic review" promised. New capital rules. Criminal enforcement of collection; a Senate-passed bill. Not a 1: about 144% a year is still allowed, and the moratorium was lifted. |
| FX: will the currency hold? | 2 | 15% | 0.30 | 31 record lows against the dollar; euro +13.2% in two years; reserves −12%; current-account deficit 6.4% of GDP. |
| Macro: can borrowers pay? | 2 | 15% | 0.30 | Growth 2.1%, inflation 7.8%, unemployment 5.4%, confidence −42.0. |
| Geopolitical: politics or conflict | 3 | 14% | 0.42 | Clashes with China at sea; typhoons; the oil shock. A 2 would give 2.12, still D. |
| Legal: recovery through courts | 2 | 12% | 0.24 | Collection-only recovery under criminally enforced rules. Foreign owners are allowed up to 100% since 2016, so ownership does not lower this score. |
| Political: stable and honest? | 2 | 12% | 0.24 | CPI 32, down from 33; scandal-driven investment collapse; impeachment trial; mass protests. |
| Sovereign: can it pay its debts? | 3 | 12% | 0.36 | BBB+ stable (S&P, April 2026); BBB negative (Fitch, April 2026); Baa2 stable (Moody's, August 2026). Debt 66.9% of GDP; deficit 6.1% of GDP (Jan–Sep); interest about 22% of revenue (₱772bn of ₱3,535bn). |
| Total | 100% | 2.26 → D | 0.34 below C, 0.46 above E. |
Arithmetic: 0.20×2 + 0.15×2 + 0.15×2 + 0.14×3 + 0.12×2 + 0.12×2 + 0.12×3 = 0.40 + 0.30 + 0.30 + 0.42 + 0.24 + 0.24 + 0.36 = 2.26. The grade bands are A 4.20+, B 3.40+, C 2.60+, D 1.80+, E below 1.80 or any veto. Country cap: D = 5% (A 40%, B 25%, C 15%, E 0%).
Vetoes:
| Better case | Worse case | |
|---|---|---|
| What happens | Oil eases, inflation falls towards 4% and the peso steadies near 70 per euro. Public works restart, and the SEC leaves the cap at 12%. | The SEC cuts the cap again, unemployment passes 6%, the peso falls another 10–20% and Fitch downgrades. |
| Scores that move | Macro, FX and regulation each 2 → 3 | Regulation, macro and FX each 2 → 1; sovereign 3 → 2 |
| Score and limit | 2.76 — C, 15% | 1.76 (1.64 with the downgrade) — E, nothing |
Our view. Grade D — High: at most 5% of a portfolio across all Philippine originators. The grade is not about the sovereign, which is investment grade. It is about four things: borrowers in the worst inflation and weakest growth for years; a regulator that has just cut the price and polices collection with the police; a currency sliding against the dollar and, more slowly, the euro; and no public data on the market's own losses. The worse case lands below the E line, so this is a D with little room.
For the company memos, weigh each lender on four points:
The percentages are our framework's common scale for comparing countries, not advice for any particular investor.
| When | What | What would change our view |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly | PSA inflation and jobs data | Inflation below 5% and unemployment below 4.5% → macro 3; unemployment above 6% → macro 1 |
| 17 Dec 2026, then about every six weeks | BSP rate decisions | A pause with falling inflation helps; an emergency hike, or the peso past 75 per euro, hurts |
| Any time | The SEC's "periodic review" of the 12% cap | Any cut → regulation 1; rerun the stress test |
| By about August 2027 | MC 20 capital deadline | Revocations of mid-sized lenders |
| House of Representatives | SB 1744 on fair debt collection | Criminal penalties on lenders → legal 1 |
| Before year-end (as reported) | Senate verdict on VP Duterte | Unrest afterwards → political 1 |
| Within 6–24 months of April 2026 | Fitch's negative outlook | A downgrade → sovereign 2 |
| Monthly | BSP reserves | Below US$90bn or 5 months of imports → FX 1 |
| June–November | Typhoons; El Niño (headline) | A major Luzon storm hits borrowers directly |
| At sea | Scarborough and Second Thomas Shoals | Any armed exchange → geopolitical 2 |
Capital at risk. Crowdfunding investments are not covered by deposit guarantee schemes, can lose part or all of their value, and may be hard to sell before the end of their term. This guide is information, not personal investment advice.
Was this helpful?
Keep reading
Defaults at Lendwise, NEO Finance, The Money Platform and EvenFi, plus news from SAVY, Mustard, Digilo, Unbolted and JustUs for direct P2P lenders.
Record growth at PeerBerry, higher rates at robo.cash, Black Friday cashback at Lendermarket, Esketit and LOANCH, and new Notes on Mintos.
Five P2P platforms pay Black Friday cashback in November 2026, from 1% to 5%: what each offer pays, until when, and the conditions that decide what you get.
Comments · 0