Crowdfunding platform

Crowdfunding Platform - Benkey review

No rating yet No rating yet No rating yet No rating yet No rating yet
0
Leave review
Benkey runs a EUR 180m Dutch commercial property fund (EUR 250,000 minimum) and 6-8% mortgage loans. Strong 2025 returns - but high fees and no loss data.

Benkey - Risk and return review

Risk Level
High
We rate the risk High; a higher rating means more danger to your money. Benkey publishes no loss data of any kind — no defaults, no arrears, no recoveries — despite years of lending, so there is nothing to check its record against, and that silence outweighs the reassuring features. Its own key information document rates the fund 6 on a 7-point risk scale, with a one-year losing scenario of minus 6%. The loan product is sold with an explicit on-page warning that you are investing outside AFM supervision. And the fund is barely two years old — its own prospectus lists limited track record among the risks.
Return Level
Medium
The 38.8% is what the fund says it returned in 2025 — its best year, which Benkey itself calls exceptional; 2024 delivered 12.8%, and the total since the August 2024 launch is about 66%. Almost all of that is rising valuations of buildings the fund still owns — gains on paper, not money paid out — so we hold the return rating at Medium rather than taking the headline at face value. Benkey's own regulator-required key document tells a soberer story: 8.5% a year in its middle scenario over seven years, after costs.
Risk Return Level
Bad
The advertised numbers look generous, but the realistic deal is thinner than it appears. On the fund, roughly 5% a year of running costs plus a 35% performance fee above a 7.5% hurdle sit between the buildings' returns and you — which is why the regulator-required middle scenario lands at 8.5%, not 15%. Exit fees up to 8% punish leaving early, and the manager can suspend redemptions entirely. You lose money if Dutch commercial property falls — the fund's one-year bad case is minus 6% — or, on the loans, if a borrower defaults and the mortgaged building fetches less than 75% of its valuation.

Benkey - Returns and loss rates

Returns
Fixed interest: 38.80% The 38.8% is the net return Benkey reports for the 2025 calendar year on its property fund — its best year, which it calls exceptional; 2024 was 12.8% and the total since the August 2024 start is about 66% at 31 July 2026. It is mostly gains on paper from revaluing buildings still owned, before exit fees, and is not a rate anyone should expect to repeat.
Loss Rates
Risk costs: 0.00% No risk number exists: Benkey has never published a default, arrears, loss or recovery figure for its loans, and the fund is too young for a loss record. The only quantified risk statement is the fund's own key document, dated November 2024, rating it 6 on a 7-point scale with a minus 6% one-year bad case. Our High rating reflects that silence, not a measured loss rate.

Benkey – Platform statistics 2026

Information updated at: 21 Sep 2026
Number of investors 300 investors
13 projects funded
180.0M EUR funded amount

Benkey – Pros & Cons

PROS
A real, visible portfolio: thirteen Dutch commercial properties worth 180 million euros at July 2026, over 200 tenants including KLM, and more than 15 million euros in annual rent.
AFM-verified credentials: exemption 19000069 on the regulator's register since November 2021, with a full fund-management licence applied for in October 2025.
Strong reported results so far: 12.8% in 2024 and 38.8% in 2025, against a 12-15% yearly target.
The loan product is conservative on paper: first-ranking mortgage, maximum 75% loan-to-value, fixed 6-8% net paid monthly over 12 to 36 months.
Serious institutional plumbing: assets held by a separate legal-owner foundation, an external custodian (CSC), a BDO audit and independent RICS-certified valuations.
CONS
This is not retail crowdfunding: 250,000 euro minimum for the fund, 100,000 per loan, and your account balance may never drop below 100,000 euros.
The real costs are steep: about 5% a year in charges per the key document plus a 35% performance fee, and exit fees of 8%, 5% or 2% depending how soon you leave.
No default, arrears or recovery figures have ever been published, there are no public deal pages to inspect, and no annual report is posted despite a named auditor.
Liquidity is at the manager's discretion: exits only at six-weekly trading days, which can be suspended, capped or delayed — the recommended holding period is seven years.
The loan product carries Benkey's own printed warning that you are investing outside AFM supervision — no licence or prospectus requirement applies.

About Benkey

Benkey, run by Benkey Fund Management from Laren in the Netherlands, is not a typical crowdfunding site — it is a private property house for large investors. It offers two things.

The Benkey Property Fund, launched August 2024, owns thirteen Dutch commercial buildings — offices, light industrial and retail, including WTC Almere and a Schiphol-Rijk office mostly let to KLM — worth 180 million euros as of July 2026, with over 200 tenants and 15 million euros of yearly rent; entry costs 250,000 euros, and you can exit only at valuation-based trading days roughly every six weeks, which the manager can suspend.

The second product is loan participations of 100,000 euros or more in individual property loans, secured by a first mortgage at no more than 75% of the property's value, paying a fixed 6-8% a year monthly over 12 to 36 months — sold, as Benkey itself warns on the page, outside the supervision of the regulator AFM.

The firm holds a narrow AFM exemption for mortgage-loan intermediation (number 19000069, verified on the register), runs the fund under a light registration regime, and applied for a full fund-management licence in October 2025. Fund assets are held by a separate foundation with an external custodian and a BDO audit.

The fund targets 12-15% a year and returned 12.8% in 2024 and an exceptional 38.8% in 2025 — mostly rising property values on paper — while its own key information document rates risk 6 out of 7 and projects 8.5% a year in its middle scenario. Around 300 investors participate.

Regulation

License / Regulation: AFM exemption; AIFMD-light; loans outside AFM oversight | Licence 19000069 |

Functionality

Autoinvest: No
Deal rating: No
Secondary market: Yes

For Investors

Limitations: Benkey is open to private investors, companies, family offices, and institutional investors, with no explicit residency restriction published. Non-Dutch investors also appear to be accepted, although they are advised to seek local tax advice. Access is primarily limited by the high minimum investment amounts: €250,000 for the Benkey real-estate fund and €100,000 per real-estate loan. Because these products target larger/professional investors, the standard Dutch retail crowdfunding investor test does not apply, and no separate investment caps are published.
Minimum investment: 100000 EUR

Useful Information

Team behind the platform on benkey

Benkey was founded by Rory Bertram, whose property career dates to 2012, and is led by chief executive Niels Rientjes, appointed in 2025, who has said plainly that Benkey wants to be the best property fund in the Netherlands. Around them sit an operations chief, a financial and risk chief, a head of finance, three investment managers, four asset managers and named investor-relations contacts — 15 to 18 people depending on the count. Management says it invests alongside clients, but never says how much. Service providers do the heavy lifting: AssetCare administers the fund, Rabobank banks it, CSC Depositary is custodian and BDO audits.

Risk management after funding on benkey

For the loans, protection is structural: a first-ranking mortgage registered by notarial deed at no more than 75% of the property's value, plus personal liability of borrowers as reported secondary security — but no arrears procedure, enforcement timetable or recovery record has ever been published. For the fund, Benkey cites spreading across buildings and tenants, prudent borrowing, active management and independent valuations, while conceding a temporary or longer fall in value cannot be excluded. The manager also holds strong defensive tools that cut both ways: it can suspend or limit redemptions, extend notice periods and charge redemption fees to protect the fund — at the expense of any investor who wants out.

Costs for investors on benkey

Fund investors pay 1.5% a year management (1.3% above 2.5 million euros), plus — per the key information document — about 0.5% administration, 2% operating and 1% transaction costs a year, plus a 35% performance fee above 7.5% (25% for large tickets), plus 1% entry (0.5% during promotions) and exit fees of 8% within a year, 5% within four and 2% after. All-in, recurring costs run near 5% a year before the performance fee — the gap between the 12-15% marketing and the 8.5% middle scenario. Loan investors pay nothing extra: the 6-8% is quoted net.

Negative publicity or reviews on benkey

One adverse item and a striking silence. Het Financieele Dagblad reported that a judge dismissed Benkey's own complaint about theft of customer data — Benkey brought the case and lost; the article sits behind a paywall and the underlying judgment could not be located, so the details remain unread. Beyond that, there is almost no independent investor voice at all: no accessible Trustpilot profile exists, one Dutch review site shows a single 9-out-of-10 review from August 2026, and Benkey's own 4.5-star claim names no source, count or date. No AFM warning, sanction, insolvency or enforcement action was found, and the register shows the exemption active. Read the quiet correctly: with roughly 300 large-ticket investors, absence of complaints is not evidence of performance — there is simply no crowd to complain.

Project selection process on benkey

For the fund, the process is documented: the investment team analyses location, property type, rental potential, condition, market and growth prospects, with legal, financial, commercial and technical due diligence; an independent, RICS- and NRVT-certified external valuer prices each building; and a separate investment committee takes the final decision. The mandate itself filters deals: Dutch commercial property of 3 to 50 million euros per object, no residential, no speculative transformation, at least half the fund in the Netherlands. For the loans, borrowers must bring 20% of their own money, a recent appraisal and a clean credit record, against a first mortgage at maximum 75% of value. No acceptance rate or committee membership is published.

Rating

Total Rating 0
No rating yet No rating yet No rating yet No rating yet No rating yet
Offering quality 0
Services and support 0
Functionality 0
Transparency 0

Reviews

Sort by:
Most recent Oldest first More likes More dislikes
Sort by rating:
Highest to lowest Lowest to highest

Alternative to Benkey

Ablrate GB

Real Estate SME loans
Min. Investment €100
Total Funded €76.79M

Anaxago FR

Real Estate Startups SME loans
Regulated
Return Level Medium
Risk Level High
Risk Return Level
Min. Investment €1000
Total Funded €939.0M

Bergfurst DE

Real Estate
Min. Investment €10
Total Funded €192.29M

Blend Network GB

Real Estate
Min. Investment €1000
Total Funded €57.01M

Bricksave GB

Real Estate
Min. Investment €1000

Brickstarter EE

Real Estate
Min. Investment €50